Vikipeedia:Üldine arutelu: erinevus redaktsioonide vahel
Eemaldatud sisu Lisatud sisu
817. rida:
:::::--<small> [[User:とある白い猫|とある白い猫]]</small> <sup>[[User talk:とある白い猫|chi?]]</sup> 30. august 2015, kell 20:11 (EEST)
:::::: {{ping|とある白い猫}} There are still few pages missing: campaigns and participants. I have a question about the word lists. You say that the words in the lists originate from reverted revisions (and browsing the generated list, one can recognize some of the words used by vandals in Estonian Wikipedia in the past). Some of these words are not offensive in any way, but nevertheless were used by vandals. For example "animal", "kill", "tšmir" (the last one is not even a word in any language I know), etc. Should these non-offensive words that were actually used by some vandals, be included in the badwords list? I'm trying to understand how the word lists are used by the software. <span style="background:#FFB84D;border:solid 1px;border-radius:8px;box-shadow:darkgray 2px 2px 2px"> [[Kasutaja:Cumbril|<span style="font-family:Old English Text MT;color:#175B17;">Taavi</span>]]|[[Kasutaja arutelu:Cumbril|✉]] </span> 30. august 2015, kell 20:44 (EEST)
:::::::We are not too concerned with how offensive the word is. We also do not care if they are meaningful. Consider these two questions:
:::::::#"Would you normally revert a revision containing it in any page?" (these would be "bad words")
:::::::#"Would you normally revert a revision containing it only in articles?" (these would be "informal words")
:::::::In English Wikipedia for example we see words like "Wheels", "Jew" and "Nazi" dominating vandalism. None of these words are ''offensive'' like swear words are. If the algorithm detects the addition of such words in an article on relevant topics (say Nazi in articles on WW2) it wouldn't flag it outright. This is the power of AI (chisel) over your edit filters (sledgehammer). Feel free to add words that you would expect to see in revisions you would revert that our TF-IDF approach did not detect. We trust the intuition of members of the community.
:::::::--<small> [[User:とある白い猫|とある白い猫]]</small> <sup>[[User talk:とある白い猫|chi?]]</sup> 1. september 2015, kell 20:54 (EEST)
==kriipsuskript==
| |||